Butcher Block vs Granite Countertops: The Better Choice

If you’re considering a kitchen remodeling or are designing a new one, choosing the ideal countertop for your cooking area is of paramount importance. The right countertop fabric will make cooking effortless and practical. So, between butcher block vs granite countertops, which one will you move for? 

This article delivers an entire lowdown concerning both types. You could then select the perfect kitchen countertop to your home. In fact, you’ll use a similar parameters for your bathroom remodeling too.  

Image by way of kirkandmimi from Pixabay CC0
Countertop MaterialProsCons 
Butcher Block Countertops
  • Traditional looking
  • Cheaper 
  • Easy installation
  • Great for direct chopping
  • Eco-friendly
  • Needs regular treatment/ refinishing
  • Not totally water or heat-resistant
  • Limited shades and wooden species
Granite Countertops
  • Beautiful to seem at
  • Modern
  • Lots of colors, pattern options
  • Unique variations
  • Durable
  • Heat-and-water resistant
  • Expensive 
  • Installation merely through a professional, time-consuming
  • Measurements can’t be even a bit inaccurate
  • Needs regular sealing
  • Scratches easily with sharp objects
  • Impossible to enhance in parts

Now that we’ve got listed out the pros and cons, it’s time to examine causes that impact your choice regarding butcher block vs granite countertops.

Butcher block vs granite countertops costs

The price of a butcher block is around $1,000 to $1,500 for a 30 rectangular feet counter space (standard kitchen size). The price will of course rely upon the wooden species and the fashion of the countertop.

The complete butcher block setting up fees between $1,400 and $1,900, adding hard work price of approximately $250 and material expenses of $70 to $90. And, if the method includes yet another fabrication to compare the kitchen cabinetry — that would mean additional dollars.

Granite expenses plenty more. Its cost in keeping with rectangular foot is anything between $30 to $500! The installation, which have to merely be completed via a professional, is costlier too. It contains edging (generally $10 in keeping with linear foot), fabrication, and sink installation.

Cutouts of stainless-steel sinks are around $100 a piece. The total installation price would be upward of $3,500.  

Are you budgeting for your countertop? We can assist you! Discover among our simple and safe loan concepts to your remodel. All without affecting your credit score


Image through Csaba Nagy from Pixabay CC0

Since wood countertops weigh a lot lower than granite, installing a butcher block is easier. It does, however, require correct assist on the bottom when it comes to blocking, in any other case can result in a rickety countertop. It also should be sealed and handled properly.   

Granite counter tops are heavier and require personalized fabrication. Only a skilled expert can set up the sort of countertop. The stone must be reduce and fitted flawlessly with the cupboards — complete with a sink cut-out. You wish the exact measurements to ensure the granite fits perfectly.

Even cupboards may have to be bolstered earlier than setting up as a result of the heavyweight of the material. Except this, the epoxy must be cured appropriately too. The method is a tad tedious but nothing informed employees can’t handle.    

Granite or Quartz Silestone Worktops? Check out the differences. 


If you like the ancient warmness of the kitchens of yesteryears — go for butcher block countertops. They have a rustic allure that’s undeniable. Walnut, cherry, maple, combined wood, or birch — the suggestions are many.

But, there’s a downside to the simplistic beauty that this gives — in terms of reselling your house, the look could no longer add any resale value.

Granite countertops, at the different hand, look chic, trendy, and super-smooth. The colour or design choice is nearly endless. If you like personalized, different-looking kitchens, opt for this one. Each stone is superbly uneven. Beautifully unique.

Read more: 7 White Kitchen Counter tops for a Dreamy Kitchen


Wood must be safeguarded opposed to water and sharp objects. It must be handled with protectants inclusive of really good mineral oils from time to time. Unfortunately, the surface has the power to carry onto water and this may trigger it to be disfigured over time.

You ought to be careful not to permit any water spillage be at the counter for long. And, also make sure to treat and refinish it regularly. When you safeguard this aspect, the thick wooden is really long lasting — it doesn’t even scratch easily.  

Granite too is scratch-and-stain-resistant. However, sharp knives and different blunt goods may effortlessly mar the surface. And, once the wear is done, it’s done. There is not anything a lot you could do in terms of filling the scratch or gouge.

Granite is also liable to cracks within the surface. To ensure that any liquid spillage is cleaned up immediately. If it is going into the cracks, it may lead to discoloration or maybe bacterial growth.

Estimate theremodel costto your kitchen assignment in just some clicks with our free cost calculator. 

Ease of usage

Image by Vecislavas Popa from Pexels CC0

A butcher block countertop is a chef’s delight. Chopping, practise of nutrition can be performed right on the counter. Say goodbye to cutting boards! And this surface is simple to wash too.

If you’re not happy with prepping meals all over the place, you could set up a smaller part of butcher block on your kitchen.

Open Vs Closed Kitchens: Which Is The Better Choice? Let’s discover out!

On a granite top, you will train nutrition but chopping is a giant no-no. But, there’s some well news, these counters are heat-resistant and particularly sanitary if sealed properly. With correct care and maintenance, they are going to final you a lifetime — adding significance to your home.

Key takeaways

We’re sure, you’re now not scratching your head when it comes to the limitation of butcher block vs granite countertops. Keep in mind that whilst a butcher block is cheaper with easier installation, the granite one costs extra and may be installed simply through a professional. 

But, granite scores when it comes to a chic, popular look; the butcher block looks a tad too traditional. Granite is liable to cracks whilst the butcher block is more durable and could be refinished easily.

But, the two do share a few similarities. The two are extremely popular, utilitarian, food-safe, and brilliant to appear at. 

Examine more: Quartz Vs Granite Countertops: The Pros And Cons

Butcher Block vs Granite Countertops: The Better Choice turned into final modified: February 18th, 2021 via Ramona Sinha